Login
My Garage
New hero

Watch out: Dodgy car scam is back and catching out private sellers

By Mathilda Bartholomew | May 1, 2025

Share

Why not leave a comment?

See all | Add a comment

Selling your car privately? Watch out for the return of the "dirty oil scam" – fraudsters are sabotaging engines to force quick, lowball sales. Learn how to spot and stop it.

Watch out: Dodgy car scam is back and catching out private sellers

If you're planning to sell your car privately, heads up — a nasty old scam is doing the rounds again, and it could cost you thousands if you’re not careful.

Here’s how it works: scammers pose as potential buyers, turn up for a test drive, and then secretly mess with your car to make it look like it’s got a major issue.

Their trick? Pouring engine oil into the coolant system. This causes the engine to smoke, making it seem like there’s a serious mechanical fault.

Then comes the hustle — instead of walking away, they offer to take the “broken” car off your hands for a fraction of the asking price. Usually around a third.

These fraudsters often work in pairs: one keeps you busy asking to see the paperwork, spare wheel, or service history, while the other sabotages the engine.

This scam, nicknamed the “dirty oil trick,” has been reported multiple times in recent years — including by The Daily Mail and This is Money. Victims have narrowly avoided losing thousands.

Real Examples:

  • In 2022, Bikramjit Kooner listed his BMW 520D M Sport online. He caught two scammers on CCTV pouring oil into the coolant and smearing some on the engine. When the car started smoking, they claimed it was “f****d” and offered him £2,000 — way under value.
  • In 2019, Martin and Natasha Hill had their Audi A4 targeted via Gumtree. The scammers pulled the same trick and then tried to knock £1,000–£2,000 off the price.
  • In 2016, John Woodcock listed a BMW E39 for £1,750. Three men came to view it, distracted him, poured oil into the engine bay, and offered just £500.

Luckily, in each case the sellers spotted something was off before any long-term damage was done.

How to Avoid Getting Scammed

Here’s how to protect yourself:

  • Never meet buyers alone. Always have someone with you who can keep an eye on the car while you're talking.
  • Take time-stamped photos of your engine bay, oil dipstick, and coolant bottle before any viewings — this gives you proof if something’s tampered with.
  • Before the test drive, show the buyer you’ve checked the oil and coolant. This lets them know you’re clued up and watching.
  • Don’t leave them alone with the car — ever. If they ask to see paperwork, do it near the vehicle.
  • If you suspect tampering, don’t drive the car. Get a mechanic to flush the system before starting the engine — that could save you a serious repair bill.

Selling your car shouldn’t cost you thousands because of a lowlife scam. Stay alert, stay smart, and spread the word.

Related Articles

Could the Justy make a comeback? Subaru plots small electric rival to Renault 5
Subaru might bring back the Justy as an all-electric hatch to rival the Renault 5. Here's what we know so far.
Jul 25, 2025
EVs to lose exemption as London Congestion Charge rises in 2026
EV drivers in London will soon have to pay the Congestion Charge, with changes set to make TfL £75 million a year.
Jul 25, 2025
UK vehicle manufacturing down almost 12% in 2025 so far
UK car output plunges to a 72-year low, with production levels not seen since 1953.
Jul 25, 2025
Fuel Me Once: The True Cost of the Taxi of Mum & Dad
Motorway found that UK parents drive over 3,000 miles a year ferrying family - enough to reach Greece and back - spending an average of...
Jul 24, 2025